LANSING, MI The Republican-led Senate voted Thursday, April 14, to prevent two recent appointments to university boards. Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is a former chairman of the Republican Party.
The Republican-controlled Senate voted to disapprove Michael Ryan's appointment to the Ferris State University Board of Trustees and to disapprove Jon Hoadley's appointment to the Board of Trustees of Western Michigan. The vote to keep Ryan out was 22-16, and senators voted 20-18 to derail Hoadley's appointment.
Whitmer each had the opportunity to serve on their respective boards in February. The governor has made board appointments, but they are subject to the consent of the Michigan Senate, under state law.
Sen. Aric Nesbitt, who was the only Republican to talk on the Senate floor, said he voted to disapprove the two applicants because he believed the governor had "exercised poor judgment" in making the appointments.
Nesbitt expressed concern about Hoadley's presence at WMU, which he described as a conflict of interest, and Ryan's "long history of a combative relationship" with the Ferris State Board of Trustees.
"University boards are responsible for managing multimillion dollar budgets, setting tuitions, and ensuring the quality of education for thousands of Michigan students," Nesbitt said. "We anticipate that our governor might have identified individuals more qualified for these key positions, which in fact has improved her judgement about appointments. "In fact, recently, these boards and universities have shown improvements in this regard."
Senate Democrats criticized these claims, claiming that both candidates are highly qualified for positions.
While a student there, Sen. Jeremy Moss, D-Southfield, sued for a conflict of interest in Hoadley being appointed to the Board of Directors, according to Moss. She also claimed that a student is not in violation of the law by serving on an institution's governing board.
Moss, who said he was "incredibly depressed" by Thursday's vote, called on Republicans to explain why they blocked two appointees more. The fact that Hoadley, a former state representative, is the second homosexual appointee that Senate Republicans have been forced to remove.
Purposing LGBTQ people from participating in our educational institutions is the most comprehensive policy proposition from the Republican Party over the past several weeks and months, according to Moss.
"Certainly not as students must be able to live authentically and express themselves, or athletes from playing on teams they want to be involved. Not as teachers being capable of forcefully and accurately teach and support their students, and apparently now, not as board members of universities."
On Thursday, Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel asked the Republican-led vote, saying, "If it wasn't already clear that the Michigan Republican has declared open warfare on LGBTQ people, it should be now. Jon Hoadley is more than qualified for this position. This vote is outrageous."
Hoadley expressed his "extremely dreadful" in the Senate's Thursday speech in a posted to his Twitter account.
"I am confident that our faculty, staff, and students at WMU are doing an important job," Hoadley said. "I was adamant to continue that support without even a hearing, in my community and in the Michigan Legislature. This action, taken without even a hearing, is counter to the spirit of open debate and student that is a hallmark for higher education institutions. "I remain committed to WMU, the Kalamazoo community, and I am ready to work with anyone."
Senator Rosemayer Bayer, D-Beverly Hills, argued for Ryan's appointment on Thursday, indicating his potential as a recognized leader at Ferris State University.
Ryan served as president of the faculty association and on the Michigan Association for Higher Education Board of Directors for 40 years as a professor at Ferris State. In 2017, he retired.
Ferris is well-known for his abilities and ability to understand students, according to Bayer. "He knows the administration, their strengths and weaknesses, and he understands the opportunities the university is facing, preserving costs affordable, and strengthening relationships with Michigan community colleges and the K-12 schools. He also understands and love military experience.
Several Democrats criticized Republicans for refusing to hold hearings for appointees, where senators could have asked them questions about their credentials.
The names of gubernatorial candidates were removed from the Advice and Consent Committee, which usually review them.Neither Ryan nor Hoadley had a hearing before Thursday's Senate hearing.
The governor is now on the verge of appointing new applicants to the latter open positions, and he may even appoint the same individuals to the board again.
More on MLive: