I Wanted Her to Hear It: Paula Mulder and Maryjane Buri Murders

I Wanted Her to Hear It: Paula Mulder and Maryjane Buri Murders ...

Murders of Maryjane Buri Mulder, 48, and her daughter Paula Mulder, 21, were brutally murdered in Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey, in September 2009. The perpetrator was promptly identified, but the authorities required several hours to obtain a confession.

The first air date for the show will be on February 5th, 2023.

Official Synopsis:

A guy discovers his girlfriend and her mother murdered in their beds late at night; he calls 911 for assistance, but police later discover his desire to revenge.

What Happened to Paula Mulder and Maryjane Buri?

Paula Mulder was born in Egg Harbor Township, Atlantic County, New Jersey, on February 9, 1988, to Maryjane Buri Mulder and Patrick Joseph Mulder. After graduating from high school in Egg Harbor Township, Paula attended Atlantic Cape Community College (ACCC) between 2006 and 2007, majoring in liberal arts.

Paula is South Jersey's largest breeder of AKC Bichon Frises and a 25-year veteran of Caesars Hotel and Casino. She used her free time to prepare meals for her husband and two young girls. On September 30, 2009, Paula's boyfriend discovered blood all over their Scarborough Drive home.

Emergency personnel arrived at the property at 3:12 a.m. and discovered Maryjane, 48, and her daughter, 21 years old, both dead in different rooms from gunshot wounds. Maryjane was shot in the head and neck, causing instantaneous death.

Paula Mulder and Maryjane Buri were killed, and what was the cause?

Nicholas H. Nigro III, Paula's boyfriend, reportedly returned home at 3:04 a.m. and called 911, yelling, "My girlfriend and my mother were hurt!" According to the showrunners, Nicholas's 911 call revealed that "blood was everywhere in the house," including "all over the wall" in Maryjane's bedroom.

Nicholas was patted down, his phone was confiscated, and he was questioned by a police cruiser while waiting for police in the front yard, according to court filings.

Nicholas' residence was discovered at around 6:16 a.m., just after EMS personnel took the deceased. After hours of interrogation, the authorities concluded that Nicholas was not an exceptionally talented student who had dropped out of school before finishing his education. He lived in Paula's home and Maryjane's house.

Nicholas is described during a police interrogation as unemployed and must do odd jobs to keep his expenses under control. According to Dr. Nameeta Sahni, a medical psychologist, he displayed typical psychopath traits, such as a parasitic personality. While being filmed, he stated that he was extremely close to his girlfriend and even liked her mother.

Nicholas displayed no signs of sadness upon receiving the news, according to a forensic neuropsychologist. Jonathan Deright maintains that he concealed his emotions rather than displayed them. Nicholas changed his testimony when police questioned him about what might have led to Paula's mother.

Nicholas suspected a local cocaine dealer he only knew as "Fresh" when authorities searched him for possible suspects. His sentence is scheduled for the next week, according to the drug dealer's story.

Nicholas assumed that Fresh might have murdered his girlfriend and her mother because he owed the dealer $600,000. But the cops rejected his assertion completely and charged him with murder. Nicholas lost his composure and began fabricating stories when he realized that the cops did not trust him.

Nicholas Nigro What Is He Doing Today?

Nicholas attempted to sway the authorities by using his confession as a favor and regained control by portraying it positively. Nicholas freely confessed that his desire to keep his family away mirrored his love for them. In court testimony, Nicholas described Paula's treatment of him as "playing him for a fool" and "a tiny puppet on a string."

Nicholas was charged with two counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to 125 years in prison in April 2011. According to accounts, he was found guilty on all counts in the attempted murder of Paula.

Nicholas was given a five-year prison term for resisting arrest. He changed his story about being guilty. He said, "I would never surrender." Paula and her mother are my top favourite people in the world, according to prison records. The release date for Nicholas is December 28, 2115.


  • Law.justia.com
  • ABC News

You may also like: